On Friday afternoon, the FAA did something it does incredibly rarely. Around 4 p.m. ET, it halted departures across the United States. The FAA ground stop lasted more than four hours and impacted thousands of people across the United States, including a college football game that was moved back a day, resulting in millions in lost revenue for the surrounding businesses. Fridays are always heavy travel days, especially leading up to Thanksgiving. It’s also important to note that it happened just three days after the agency expanded a brand-new AI-powered system to the entire country. The obvious question is whether the two are related. According to officials and the company behind the technology, they aren’t.
The FAA cited a “temporary telecommunications outage” and said it grounded flights “out of an abundance of caution.” Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy later gave the most specific explanation so far. Calling the air traffic system “incredibly old,” he said routers got overloaded with data and began producing inconsistent information, so the system was shut down. He warned that without further upgrades, more disruptions could follow, and he asked Congress to pay for them.
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said Friday there was no indication the communications problems were tied to the new software, and top Transportation Department and FAA officials repeated that in the days since. Air Space Intelligence, the startup that built the system, went further, saying the ground stop wasn’t caused by its SMART product or by how it was integrated with the FAA and air traffic control, though the agency hasn’t released a full account of what actually failed.
SMART is short for Strategic Management of Airspace, Routes and Trajectories. Duffy and FAA Administrator Bryan Bedford introduced it in September as a tool that pulls roughly 200 data streams, including weather, flight paths, traffic flow, and controller staffing, into one platform. A team of specialists at a single site near Washington reviews the AI-supported analysis and sends recommendations to the FAA’s command center, which relays them to controllers. In other words, the AI makes suggestions and humans make decisions. ASI’s CEO, Phillip Buckendorf, explained in an October NPR interview: “The AI does the math,” but the human operator is “the decider.”
The FAA says early tests around Washington helped reroute 180 flights and saved an average of 10 minutes and 80 gallons of fuel per flight. One Tampa-to-Dallas flight reportedly cut 42 minutes off its trip. SMART expanded to all 22 air traffic control centers on November 10. A former FAA airspace manager says no other country has a working AI air traffic tool like it.
That’s the reason the timing was so curious to many. Last month, House Democrats asked the Government Accountability Office to audit the software, writing in an October 13 letter that front-line aviation safety workers apparently had little to no input into its development and limited training. The letter also raised the risk that the AI could interfere with experienced controllers or “hallucinate safety-critical information.” Mike O’Donnell, a former top FAA official with 17 years at the agency, says the FAA “cannot afford to be wrong” and has to keep SMART as “a tool in the toolbox,” with ways to verify what it recommends.
Outside experts have other possible explanations. Ruth Stilwell, a former air traffic controller, publicly suggested that a software problem, such as an update gone wrong in the system that handles pilot-controller communications, may have been to blame. CBS News reported that an update to the FAA’s private communications network may have triggered a system-wide reboot and crash. Both possibilities are unconfirmed as of now.
Missy Cummings, a George Mason University researcher who studies responsible AI in transportation, called the episode another example of how brittle the air transportation system is, and blamed staffing cuts under the current administration. Stilwell also pointed to the FAA being short-staffed, noting that layoffs tied to the Department of Government Efficiency hit hundreds of FAA workers last year. Stilwell even defended the shutdown itself: planes in the air are the priority, and grounded planes are safe.
Nationwide groundings are exceedingly rare. The last was about two hours in January 2023 over a notice-to-pilots system outage, and before that, the aftermath of September 11, 2001.
So did AI cause the ground stop? It doesn’t seem like it, as the stated cause is aging infrastructure. But the timing is quite a coincidence if it isn’t related. Either way, the flight industry is still recovering from Friday’s disruption. We can only hope it doesn’t happen again as we head into the holiday season.