For years, the internet had a favorite joke: something absurd would happen, and you’d say “I can’t believe it happened before GTA 6.” But that joke is dead now that Grand Theft Auto VI is officially out, and the first reviews suggest the wait was worth it.

People were clearly excited about it. Sensor Tower estimates GTA 6 generated $2.36 billion in pre-orders and first-day sales, with roughly 24.5 million copies sold. Rockstar and parent company Take-Two haven’t confirmed sales figures, but described demand as “unprecedented.” It’s $79.99 on PS5 and Xbox, with an “ultimate” edition at $99.99. (It’s also only available digitally, which has upset some gamers.)

So is it good? Most reviewers say yes.  One called it “the single most impressive video game I have ever played.” Cars have animated drivetrains, personal belongings, and visible wear, as well as damage that makes panels buckle and wheels rip off. Some say the motorcycles are the weaker point, claiming they are upright and stiff.

But the world is the real star. Vice City and the surrounding area feel more lived-in than any game out there, from traffic density to night lighting to details like sweat on a character’s forehead. The game is locked at 30 frames per second, which stirred online argument, though most gamers report that it smoothly and reliably on a standard PS5. One of the more talked-about changes is the Wanted system. Cops can only act on what they know, there’s no radar showing approaching police, and evasion means listening to the scanner and watching traffic. Banks can also be robbed in the open world, as long as you’ve unlocked the gear to deal with dye packs.

The real debate is whether GTA has gone soft. Memes about the new vibe of the game abound, but actual opinions are more complicated. Leads Jason Duval and Lucia Caminos are a pair of small-time crooks whose priority is escape, not revenge or empire building. Lucia seems to be the most multifaceted woman in the entire series, and the whole game feels shaped by a slower, more deliberate approach.

That approach shows up in the daily rhythm. Gamers have shared that it feels like daily life, starting with waking up and making breakfast or coffee to boost health and stamina. Sure, there are missions to take on. But you also may fix a leaky roof or paint your digital living room. In other words, the chores sit next to the chaos.

As for the relationship, it’s not quite as simple as some have suggested. Rockstar has said players decide whether Jason and Lucia become romantic or stay strictly platonic, with alternate dialogue recorded for each. They’ll always share a close working relationship, but the game isn’t forcing a couple on anyone. So the “lead has a girlfriend” criticism may be less accurate than it sounds, depending on how you play.

What has changed is how the game encourages behavior. Most gamers have noted a newfound focus on a more empathetic approach to locals, though you can still lash out if you want to. The stash is also limited: no bazooka from a back pocket, and weapons are kept in your car. Whether that counts as tame or just thoughtful depends on what you wanted out of GTA6.

The launch hasn’t been perfectly smooth. Players found a glitch that lets them force first-person mode, though Rockstar hasn’t said whether it’ll fix or officially add it. Plus, GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen complained that the $80 physical copies come as download codes in a box and can’t be resold. “When you buy a game, you should be able to sell it, trade it or lend it to a friend,” he said in an interview.

Still, the early verdict is that GTA 6 is a bigger, calmer and more detailed take on the series, and that the quieter moments make the chaos hit harder. If that’s the price of 13 years of expectation, the question is whether fans of the old, anarchic formula will agree: is a GTA where you fix the roof before you rob the bank the game you were waiting for?